CALLER ID (CLIP) Super NEWS for Manx International Prepaid Users

krlk

CALLER ID (CLIP) Super NEWS for Manx International Prepaid Users
Today i make a test with my 2 Manx Prepaid Simcards (sim4theworld & freeglobalsim)
Caller ID WORKS in All polish networks for MANX cards
My test list:
sim4theworld +447624 > freeglobalsim +447924 - caller ID works
freeglobalsim +447924 > sim4theworld +447624 - caller ID works
sim4theworld +447624 <---> all polish networks (plus era orange) - caller ID works
freeglobalsim +447924 <---> all polish networks (plus era orange) - caller ID works
Skype IN (polish number) <---> sim4theworld +447624 - caller ID works
Skype IN (polish number) <---> freeglobalsim +447924 - caller ID works

prion · 05-09-2007, 22:08

I did some tests. Incoming calls now have caller id on an ekit sim also, but outgoing did not show up at all....

krlk · 06-09-2007, 09:45

today i check caller id from betamax operator (for ex.: www.voipdiscount.com)
not support ID to polish operators
but to manx operators (virtual) it WORKS

Przemolog · 09-09-2007, 08:10

Quote:

Originally Posted by krlk

today i check caller id from betamax operator (for ex.: www.voipdiscount.com)
not support ID to polish operators
but to manx operators (virtual) it WORKS

Karol, check the voipdiscount rates to Poland - it's 5 cents/min (excluding VAT). And the termination rate to Big Three is 0.40 PLN/min and to Play 0.65 PLN/min (excluding VAT) what is over 10 cents now. This means that they use FCTs with Polish SIMs inside, and, what follows, they bar the caller ID. BTW, you may know sometimes such FCT companies forget barring some SIMs. E.g. I received many times CBW callbacks to Orange from Orange numbers

.
And the routing to Manx (and all roaming) SIMs is different. If a call comes to Poland with caller ID, it's habdled by the roaming partner which shouldn't destroy that ID

.

prion · 09-09-2007, 09:41

Quote:

Originally Posted by Przemolog

Karol, check the voipdiscount rates to Poland - it's 5 cents/min (excluding VAT). And the termination rate to Big Three is 0.40 PLN/min and to Play 0.65 PLN/min (excluding VAT) what is over 10 cents now. This means that they use FCTs with Polish SIMs inside, and, what follows, they bar the caller ID. BTW, you may know sometimes such FCT companies forget barring some SIMs. E.g. I received many times CBW callbacks to Orange from Orange numbers

.
And the routing to Manx (and all roaming) SIMs is different. If a call comes to Poland with caller ID, it's habdled by the roaming partner which shouldn't destroy that ID

.

I think that these termination rates are valid for the internal market only (e.g. inside Poland). For calls originating from outside of the country other rules prevail. Poland is generally a country with low mobile rates, when these are dialed from abroad as compared to Italy, Greece for example.

Przemolog · 10-09-2007, 09:34

Quote:

Originally Posted by prion

I think that these termination rates are valid for the internal market only (e.g. inside Poland). For calls originating from outside of the country other rules prevail. Poland is generally a country with low mobile rates, when these are dialed from abroad as compared to Italy, Greece for example.

The termination rates for international traffic can't differ much (neither higher nor lower) simply because the difference would be used by service providers. If rates to Poland mobiles from abroad are relatively low, especially they are lower than 10 cents excluding VAT, it is achieved by large-scale FCT termination in my country. And FCTs are used because retail rates for M2M on-net calls, and in some cases even M2M off-net calls are often much lower than wholesale terminations rates in mobile networks.
Going (at least partially) back, to the main topic: of course, those FCT low rates result in missing or incorrect caller ID on international calls coming to Poland from abroad (or from local VoIP providers as well

). If caller ID for incoming calls is an important issue, then this is a reason for which it may be better to use a foreign roaming SIM (either national or international) instead of a local one...

bbob · 11-09-2007, 20:18

works great now with caller id working. On the belgium and dutch networks I get caller ID. This was the last thing missing from the Manx sim.

I do have a new UM+ sim (free update) but don't want to use it because of the many problems people seem to have.

The Manx sims seem to be the best now, caller id, +44 number.

sailorbg · 11-09-2007, 21:07

I use my Globalsim arround many of EU countries. There is no plase I visit with working CLIP. BUT and wat impress me most is that BETAMAX Voip providers I use (lowratevoip & justvoip) give caller ID.

prion · 12-09-2007, 05:48

Quote:

Originally Posted by sailorbg

I use my Globalsim arround many of EU countries. There is no plase I visit with working CLIP. BUT and wat impress me most is that BETAMAX Voip providers I use (lowratevoip & justvoip) give caller ID.

I also use betamax and always see caller is a number like 70xxxxxx. What about you? Do you see the same or something else?

bbob · 12-09-2007, 19:49

I use pbxes.com for incoming voip calls, (voip did numbers from different countries) The calls parallel are also forwarded to my mobile using voicetrading (betamax) and I always see the +31xxx code that I use to forward the calls.

The mobile is also an extension within pbxes and when for example extension 105 calls by mobile I see +105 as called ID so I know that extension is calling.

	(#1)
krlk (Offline) Junior Member Amateur Member Posts: 26 Join Date: 21 Jan 2007 Country:	CALLER ID (CLIP) Super NEWS for Manx International Prepaid Users - 05-09-2007, 18:02 CALLER ID (CLIP) Super NEWS for Manx International Prepaid Users Today i make a test with my 2 Manx Prepaid Simcards (sim4theworld & freeglobalsim) Caller ID WORKS in All polish networks for MANX cards My test list: sim4theworld +447624 > freeglobalsim +447924 - caller ID works freeglobalsim +447924 > sim4theworld +447624 - caller ID works sim4theworld +447624 <---> all polish networks (plus era orange) - caller ID works freeglobalsim +447924 <---> all polish networks (plus era orange) - caller ID works Skype IN (polish number) <---> sim4theworld +447624 - caller ID works Skype IN (polish number) <---> freeglobalsim +447924 - caller ID works My Phones: Nokia 6310i, 2310, 6280, SPV M650, SE T290i; My VoIP Phones: wifi Linksys WIP330; wifi BELKIN (Skype), Linksys Gates PostPaid: Orange Idea PL PrePaids "Working": PL: SimPlus (plusgsm), PoP (orange), mbank(mvno plusgsm), snickers (mvno orange); INT: +447642 Easy Roam PrePaids "Deceased": UK: O2, Vodafone, FreeGlobalSim, Sim4TheWorld; My VoIP operators: skype, & BETAMAX

	(#2)
prion (Offline) Senior Member Prepaid Pioneer Posts: 589 Join Date: 01 May 2006 Location: Greece Country:	05-09-2007, 22:08 I did some tests. Incoming calls now have caller id on an ekit sim also, but outgoing did not show up at all....

	(#3)
krlk (Offline) Junior Member Amateur Member Posts: 26 Join Date: 21 Jan 2007 Country:	06-09-2007, 09:45 today i check caller id from betamax operator (for ex.: www.voipdiscount.com) not support ID to polish operators but to manx operators (virtual) it WORKS My Phones: Nokia 6310i, 2310, 6280, SPV M650, SE T290i; My VoIP Phones: wifi Linksys WIP330; wifi BELKIN (Skype), Linksys Gates PostPaid: Orange Idea PL PrePaids "Working": PL: SimPlus (plusgsm), PoP (orange), mbank(mvno plusgsm), snickers (mvno orange); INT: +447642 Easy Roam PrePaids "Deceased": UK: O2, Vodafone, FreeGlobalSim, Sim4TheWorld; My VoIP operators: skype, & BETAMAX

	(#7)
bbob (Offline) Senior Member Prepaid Expert Posts: 499 Join Date: 20 Feb 2007 Country:	11-09-2007, 20:18 works great now with caller id working. On the belgium and dutch networks I get caller ID. This was the last thing missing from the Manx sim. I do have a new UM+ sim (free update) but don't want to use it because of the many problems people seem to have. The Manx sims seem to be the best now, caller id, +44 number.

	(#8)
sailorbg (Offline) Junior Member Newbie Posts: 8 Join Date: 12 May 2007 Country:	11-09-2007, 21:07 I use my Globalsim arround many of EU countries. There is no plase I visit with working CLIP. BUT and wat impress me most is that BETAMAX Voip providers I use (lowratevoip & justvoip) give caller ID. Prepaid GSM: Mtel(bg), Globul(bg), Vivatel(bg), Vodofone(gr), Vodagone(uk), Wind(it), Golobalsim

	(#10)
bbob (Offline) Senior Member Prepaid Expert Posts: 499 Join Date: 20 Feb 2007 Country:	12-09-2007, 19:49 I use pbxes.com for incoming voip calls, (voip did numbers from different countries) The calls parallel are also forwarded to my mobile using voicetrading (betamax) and I always see the +31xxx code that I use to forward the calls. The mobile is also an extension within pbxes and when for example extension 105 calls by mobile I see +105 as called ID so I know that extension is calling.